As a Persian-Canadian I’m compelled to write about the Iranian election and yet, while the urge is more intrinsic than from peer pressure, I’m apprehensive to investigate my thoughts on the matter because it deals with a part of my identity that has scarcely been provoked like this in the past.
I’ve never been a nationalist, mostly because Iranian culture reeks of nationalist fervor and I simply cannot identify with the flagrant displays of jingoism. For this reason (among others), I am disconnected from Persian culture because I haven’t really found models of cultural expression that suit my personality and preferences. While I am fully aware that being confounded with such an identity crisis is the quintessential cliched phenomenon for immigrants/first gen kids, it is difficult for me to even comprehend that people have had the words to classify it as a phenomenon, because I certainly have trouble talking about it.
It’s important to understand that as “white” as I am, there is still a part of me that identifies with the country my parents left behind.
I worry about my family in Iran but rumination is useless when there is literally not a single thing that can be done. Truthfully, the feelings I have about the state of the country are harder to shake. It’s easy to have faith in cousins who can take care of themselves. I don’t exactly have — or ever had — faith in the emotionally and religiously fueled political systems of Iran.
I’m still trying to figure out my position within the context of Iran’s recent worldwide media attention. Immigrants have all had the lovely experience of correcting ignorant statements made about their culture — we’ve collected an entire life’s worth of them. When the discourse about one’s home country becomes suddenly more intense and concentrated in a short period of time, being suddenly thrown into the hot seat is unnerving. I am compelled to speak up about #iranelection but feel no more qualified on the issue than the average non-Iranian, and I get easily tongue-tied because I don’t want to bring in my jadedness into the conversation. Mix that in with the previously described cliched first-gen guilt, plus of course the worry for relatives, and then the emotional baggage that Iran’s harrying political environment carries and it all leads to… nausea.
Iranians are stereotypically emotional and this is no more evident than when you get them rabble-rousing about politics. The emotions are well-warranted. So many of us had to leave after 1979 or during the Iran-Iraq war. Many of us lost family and friends and never got the closure we needed for their deaths because of the inhumane actions of the government. It has become quite evident over the past 30 years that there is no hope for Iran.
I understood from a young age that the country’s theocratic grip was impossible to overcome. I say this in spite of the 80s baby boom, a generation that is constantly cited by Westerners as the promising future for democracy in Iran. Even though many of these well-educated Iranians are well aware of corruption and how their country compares to others, the role of religion has become so prominent in their daily lives that the idea of a secular government sounds like a sure sign towards Western decadence. The Iranians who do support secular government are either ex-pats or have been threatened into silence for so long that there is no hope of ever leading a grassroots secular movement. The only reason the current protests are successful is because they are spearheaded by moderate theocratic politicians who have the experience and power to successfully organize such a movement. I don’t think any possibility for a revolution in Iran at this time will lead to the utopian, secular democracy that so many of us desire.
My lack of hope for Iran’s future is part of this aversion of fostering a sense of Persian-ness. I know I will never go back. I acknowledge that my Persian-ness will only ever amount to so much of my personality, and yet of course there is that ever-present guilt thing, which I believe is a result of a sheer curiosity about my roots and being able to make sense of a language, culture, and non-Western perspective that makes up a part of my socialization.
I have no conclusion to this entry and I’ve been trying to write it for days so I will conclude it here by saying: sure, let there be a revolution, but don’t for one second believe that Iran will transform into a democracy.


